Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Former Francis Stalwart Flips on the Traditional Mass

N. B. Evidently the atmosphere in Rome and elsewhere is less fearful now. I wonder why …

Mark Lambert @sitsio:

Here is a cardinal who served for years among Pope Francis's closest advisers, yet now openly says he would not favour prohibiting the spread of the traditional liturgy, provided Vatican II is respected.

This is very welcome, but it raises an awkward question. Where were these voices when Traditionis custodes was introduced, severely restricting precisely the liturgical life that Gracias now seems happy to accommodate? Perhaps his thinking has evolved. Perhaps he always held these views but chose not to challenge the previous pontificate publicly. We cannot know, but one cannot help wondering whether a change of Pope has made it easier for senior churchmen to express reservations about policies they previously appeared content to accept?

If that is the case, it raises a rather uncomfortable question about the culture of candour within the Church. We have heard an extraordinary amount about synodality, listening and speaking freely over the past decade. Surely that freedom must extend to questioning papal policies, particularly when those policies have caused considerable pastoral suffering among Catholics who remain entirely faithful to Rome?

I welcome Cardinal Gracias's intervention. I only wish we had heard more such voices five years ago.



No comments:


Thank you for visiting.

Followers

Kamsahamnida, Dziekuje, Terima kasih, Doh je, Grazie, Tesekur, Gracias, Dank u, Shukran

free counters