The Day Everything Seemed Lost
Good Friday is the most realistic day in the Christian year. It does not flatter appearances. It does not pretend that the visible rulers of religion will always be faithful, that civil authority will defend innocence, or that the crowd will love truth when truth stands before it. It shows us the opposite. Priests conspire. A governor caves. The mob howls. Friends scatter. Christ is led out to die.
Hiraeth In Exile is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a paid subscriber.
That is why Good Friday speaks so sharply to Catholics living through a battered and humiliated age. We look around and see bishops rewarding confusion, punishing fidelity, and treating tradition as the problem while the real vandals are welcomed as pastors. We see a Catholic media class forever promising that the next gesture, the next appointment, the next Roman signal will turn the tide, even as the tide keeps coming in. We see many who once spoke boldly rediscovering caution just when caution serves the wrong men.
Good Friday does not tell us that such things are normal in the sense of being good. It tells us they are possible in the history of the Church because they were present at the center of the Passion itself. The crisis of the Church did not begin when pagans attacked from outside. It reached its most terrible form when the men closest to the sacred used their position against the Lord.
The Religious Class Chose Safety
The horror of Calvary is not only that Christ was killed. It is that He was killed through a collaboration of sacred office, political cowardice, and public pressure.
The chief priests wanted Him gone. Pilate knew better, but feared the consequences of doing right. The crowd preferred Barabbas. Each party could tell itself a story. The priests defended order. Pilate preserved stability. The crowd followed emotion. Together they built the road to the Cross.
There is the permanent warning. Men in office do not cease being dangerous because their office is holy. In fact, when holy office is detached from faith, courage, and love of truth, it becomes more dangerous. It gains the ability to wound souls while still speaking the language of religion.
That is why Catholics should not let themselves be hypnotized by rank, platform, or reputation. A miter does not guarantee fidelity. A collar does not guarantee courage. A blue-check Catholic commentator does not guarantee honesty. On Good Friday, the most respectable men in the room were among the worst men in the room.
Pilate Is Always with Us
Pilate remains one of the most modern figures in Scripture because he represents the man who sees the truth, fears the crowd, and chooses self-protection.
He is not driven by conviction. He is driven by calculation. He does not love justice enough to suffer for it. He wants a solution that preserves his position, quiets the noise, and keeps his hands outwardly clean. He fails because that combination does not exist. A man either defends the innocent or helps condemn Him.
How many churchmen and Catholic public figures now live in Pilate’s shadow? They know the wreckage is real. They know the bad appointments are bad. They know the old faith is being treated as disposable while novelty is treated as vitality. But they also know that saying this too plainly could cost them access, invitations, standing, favor, perhaps even future advancement. So they wash their hands in public phrases and careful omissions.
Good Friday tells us what such prudence is worth.
The Faithful Were Few
Yet Good Friday is not merely a study in betrayal. It is also a revelation of what fidelity looks like when almost everything visible has gone wrong.
Our Lady remains. John remains. The holy women remain. Joseph of Arimathea steps forward. Nicodemus comes with reverence. None of them control events. None of them can stop the execution. None of them look powerful. Yet they are the beautiful part of the scene.
That is a profound consolation for Catholics who feel abandoned, sidelined, or pushed into corners by the official life of the Church. The faithful remnant at Calvary did not win the afternoon. It did something harder. It remained faithful in defeat.
That is often the task assigned to Catholics in times of eclipse. Not to conquer visibly. Not to receive institutional praise. Not to be numerous. Simply to remain with Christ when remaining with Christ costs something.
The Cross Is Still the Measure
Modern churchmanship prefers a religion without too much severity. It wants accompaniment without judgment, mercy without repentance, community without sacrifice, Easter without Good Friday. But the old religion has never permitted that illusion. The world was redeemed by the Blood of the Lamb, not by the management of appearances.
That is why the Cross still judges every false solution now being offered. No marketing campaign can save the Church. No carefully worded ambiguity can restore what has been broken. No sentimental appeal to unity can make corruption harmless. The Church will not be healed by pretending the wounds are shallow.
She will be healed the way she was founded: by truth, sacrifice, suffering, repentance, and fidelity to Christ above every earthly arrangement.
Why Good Friday Gives Hope
At first glance Good Friday seems like the least hopeful day of the year. In reality it is the day that destroys false hope so that true hope can begin.
False hope says the Church must always look successful. True hope says Christ reigns even when His cause appears crushed.
False hope says officeholders will save us if we wait long enough. True hope says Christ remains King even when officeholders fail.
False hope says we should judge by headlines, appointments, and public momentum. True hope says Calvary itself looked like defeat until heaven revealed what had really happened.
That is the lesson for Catholics now. Do not mistake humiliation for abandonment. Do not mistake numbers for truth. Do not mistake official favor for divine approval. On Good Friday, truth was condemned, abandoned, mocked, and nailed up for the world to stare at. Yet Good Friday was not the triumph of evil. It was the beginning of its destruction.
So remain with Christ. Stay near our Mother. Refuse the narcotic of excuses. Let the clever men keep explaining why now is not the time. Let the managers keep managing decline. Let the crowd shout.
They had their hour once before.
Christ still won.
