Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Traditionis custodes and a lesson in Romanita’


Michael Haynes:

“BREAKING: Pope Leo comments on Latin Mass restrictions & Traditionis Custodes  ––– ‘we will continue to follow it’

“Questioned on the papal plane about changing TC, Leo replied:

“‘Traditionis Custodes was a decision by Pope Francis, and we will continue to follow it. 

“Traditionis Custodes includes the possibility of granting a dispensation or permitting the celebration of Mass according to the Vetus Ordo. 

“And so, once again, for the unity of the Church, the overwhelming majority of Catholics worldwide celebrate the Vatican II Rite, that of Paul VI, and we will continue to do so. 

There is a path available for those who wish to request a dispensation.’”


Murray Rundus @MurrayRundus:

“I find it funny how overnight some commentary went from:

“‘Of course Pope Leo will get rid of Traditionis! He’s obviously not on board with it. Stop being so pessimistic!’

“To:

“‘Thank the Lord our sweet vicar doesn’t think we should execute every traditional priest on sight.’

Damian Thompson @holysmoke:

“I find it funny that you took seriously any commentator who has said recently that the Pope was going to scrap TC. On successive visits to Rome I’ve been told that he’d let it wither on the vine rather than scrap it. *If* the trads played their cards right, which they most certainly haven’t.”

N.B. “Let it wither on the vine” is code for Romanita’,  a slow process in which everyone’s need for bella figura is satisfied and through which most parties involved are enabled to get most of what they want.

Former Francis Stalwart Flips on the Traditional Mass

N. B. Evidently the atmosphere in Rome and elsewhere is less fearful now. I wonder why …

Mark Lambert @sitsio:

Here is a cardinal who served for years among Pope Francis's closest advisers, yet now openly says he would not favour prohibiting the spread of the traditional liturgy, provided Vatican II is respected.

This is very welcome, but it raises an awkward question. Where were these voices when Traditionis custodes was introduced, severely restricting precisely the liturgical life that Gracias now seems happy to accommodate? Perhaps his thinking has evolved. Perhaps he always held these views but chose not to challenge the previous pontificate publicly. We cannot know, but one cannot help wondering whether a change of Pope has made it easier for senior churchmen to express reservations about policies they previously appeared content to accept?

If that is the case, it raises a rather uncomfortable question about the culture of candour within the Church. We have heard an extraordinary amount about synodality, listening and speaking freely over the past decade. Surely that freedom must extend to questioning papal policies, particularly when those policies have caused considerable pastoral suffering among Catholics who remain entirely faithful to Rome?

I welcome Cardinal Gracias's intervention. I only wish we had heard more such voices five years ago.



Tuesday, November 17, 2026

New: Catholic noises coming from “German Synodal Way”?

Mark Lambert @sitsio:

Is Pope Leo XIV quietly succeeding where years of confrontation with Germany’s bishops have failed?

Something rather interesting seems to be happening to Germany’s controversial Synodal Way and I wonder whether we are beginning to see the fruits of Pope Leo XIV’s approach? Speaking to his fellow European bishops in Salzburg, Bishop Heiner Wilmer, chairman of the German Bishops’ Conference, has insisted that the German Church wants to remain in full communion with the Pope, faithful to the Magisterium & respectful of canon law. He also explicitly rejected the idea of a specifically German path that would separate the country's Catholics from the universal Church.

Now, you might reasonably wonder why a Catholic bishop should need to reassure his brother bishops of such elementary principles! But that is precisely what makes his intervention so interesting...For years, Germany’s Synodal Way has pursued proposals concerning Church governance, sexual morality & the exercise of episcopal authority that have generated profound tensions with Rome. Yet under Leo XIV, the proposed permanent Synodal Conference remains without Vatican approval, its planned November inauguration has been postponed, and the language coming from Germany's episcopal leadership is becoming noticeably more conciliatory.

Is this evidence that Leo’s quieter, more patient exercise of papal authority is beginning to bear fruit? I think it may be! We should not get carried away, Wilmer has not abandoned the reform agenda and Rome was already challenging aspects of the German process under Francis. A change of tone is not necessarily a change of conviction. Nevertheless, there is something encouraging about a German episcopal leader publicly acknowledging that synodality cannot become a vehicle for national ecclesiastical independence.

The real test will come when Rome says no. Will the German bishops accept that judgement, or regard it as merely another obstacle to be negotiated away? After all, authentic synodality means walking together, and the Catholic Church can only walk together cum Petro et sub Petro. Perhaps Leo XIV is beginning to remind Germany of that fundamental truth without having to make a great deal of noise about it.

Head of German bishops: We want ‘full communion’ with the Pope

Bishop Wilmer’s comments to the European bishops indicate the pressure the German episcopate is facing from the Vatican, which is pushing back on plans for the Synodal Conference.

Michael Haynes 
More: https://x.com/sitsio/status/2117589284047802810?a=Pf9Oe0iQl8jMPOZHhN0&s=46

Monday, November 16, 2026

Dixit insípiens in corde suo: * non est Deus.

 


Psalmus 13 [1]
13:1 Dixit insípiens in corde suo: * non est Deus.
13:1 Corrúpti sunt, et abominábiles facti sunt in stúdiis suis: * non est qui fáciat bonum, non est usque ad unum.
13:2 Dóminus de cælo prospéxit super fílios hóminum, * ut vídeat si est intéllegens, aut requírens Deum.
13:3 Omnes declinavérunt, simul inútiles facti sunt: * non est qui fáciat bonum, non est usque ad unum.
13:3 Sepúlcrum patens est guttur eórum: linguis suis dolóse agébant * venénum áspidum sub lábiis eórum.
13:3 Quorum os maledictióne et amaritúdine plenum est: * velóces pedes eórum ad effundéndum sánguinem.
13:3 Contrítio et infelícitas in viis eórum, et viam pacis non cognovérunt: * non est timor Dei ante óculos eórum.
13:4 Nonne cognóscent omnes qui operántur iniquitátem, * qui dévorant plebem meam sicut escam panis?
13:5 Dóminum non invocavérunt, * illic trepidavérunt timóre, ubi non erat timor.
13:6 Quóniam Dóminus in generatióne justa est, consílium ínopis confudístis: * quóniam Dóminus spes ejus est.
13:7 Quis dabit ex Sion salutáre Israël? * cum avérterit Dóminus captivitátem plebis suæ, exsultábit Jacob, et lætábitur Israël.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Black is Back

 Sacerdos in Aternum @SacerdosMariae:

Today, November 2, I will celebrate Holy Mass with a black chasuble.

A color that for centuries accompanied the Church's prayer for its deceased and which today we scarcely see in our parishes.

Its disappearance deserves reflection. 🧵

1️⃣ The Second Vatican Council never prohibited black chasubles.

The General Instruction of the Roman Missal (n. 346) still permits their use in Masses for the dead, where it is customary.

It is not a traditionalist extravagance. It is a legitimate option in the current liturgy.

2️⃣ In the post-conciliar period, many black chasubles were shoved aside, discarded, or simply forgotten.

In some places, a liturgical heritage of enormous value was destroyed for being considered outdated or incompatible with conciliar renewal.

What a mistake!

3️⃣ The idea spread that black represented a sad, gloomy, and pessimistic view of death, incompatible with Christian hope.

But the Church had used it for centuries without ever ceasing to proclaim the resurrection of Jesus Christ.

4️⃣ Black is the color of mourning. And Christians are also in mourning when we lose a loved one.

Jesus wept at Lazarus's tomb, even though he knew he would raise him.

Was his weeping contrary to hope?

5️⃣ Christian faith does not require us to conceal pain or pretend that death is unimportant.

Death is the consequence of sin and the last enemy to be destroyed, as St. Paul teaches.

Precisely for that reason, we need the victory of the risen Christ.

6️⃣ The black chasuble also expresses the gravity of our prayer for the deceased.

The Church does not automatically canonize those who die. It commends them to divine mercy and offers suffrages for them.

The Mass for the dead is, above all, a prayer of intercession.

7️⃣ Purple is also legitimate and has its own meaning.

But we do not need to reduce the full symbolic richness of the liturgy to a single color.

Purple especially highlights penance; black expresses grief and our mortal condition.

Both have their place.

8️⃣ Nor is there a contradiction between black and paschal hope.

The Christian can weep because he loves and hope because he believes.

Hope does not consist in denying the reality of death, but in knowing that Christ has conquered it.

One does not exclude the other.

9️⃣ It saddens me to think of so many ancient chasubles that ended up abandoned or destroyed.

Many were authentic works of art, crafted with care and offered for divine worship.

Liturgical renewal should never be confused with contempt for what has been received.

🔟 I do not argue that everyone must use black, nor that celebrating in purple is done worse.

I defend something much simpler: that we not despise a legitimate tradition of the Church or lose, through prejudice, the richness of its signs.

Today I will wear a black chasuble and proclaim the resurrection of Christ.

I will pray for the deceased, for their purification, and for their eternal rest.

Because black does not mean despair. It means that we take death, judgment, mercy, and eternal life seriously.

And because the light of Easter does not need us to eliminate mourning in order to keep shining.

The Church knows how to weep for its dead because it loves them. And it knows how to pray for them because it believes in eternal life.

#FielesDifuntos #Liturgia #CasullaNegra #2DeNoviembre



Saturday, November 14, 2026

Looking back at Leo’s own ars celebrandi & style of liturgical governance for answers: The TLM & St. Peter’s

 Josh Mansfield  

In looking at her writings & talks, Sister Elena seems to fit the mold of a Leonine liturgical canditate, considering the Chicago-born Pope’s own liturgical aptness.

Father Jorge Millán of the Pope’s former Peruvian Diocese of Chiclayo, which the Holy Father will visit in November, told the Pillar’s Edgar Beltran in May 2025 that, as Bishop Prevost, “He was a very ‘say the black, do the red’ kind of priest. He always celebrated with the solemnity required by the liturgy, not more, not less. He was always properly vested,” with former Vicar General Fr. Bernardino Gil noting, “He’s a very smart, well-rounded man, and he always gave care to all aspects of the liturgy.”

Many have noted the Holy Father’s liturgical sensabilities as Pope, restoring the use of the mozetta & stole during his first apperance, bringing back his coat of arms embroidered on his fascia at Christmas last year, wearing the pontifical dalmatic for ordinations & canonizations, & frequently having to search for the crucifix to incense during Mass when it’s not centered.

The Pillar reported in August from sources inside the Vatican that, while the Pope respects the 76-year old Cardinal Arthur Roche, whose five year term as Divine Worship Prefect expired in May of this year, for his handling of German liturgical affairs, Leo plans to continue to grant broader permission for the Traditional Latin Mass. This was noted especially in messages to the French & British Episcopal Conferences by Cardinal Pietro Parolin & France Nuncio Archbishop Miguel Buendia respectively. “It’s not a liturgical issue, but an issue of communion. If you’re in communion with the Church, we should allow for reasonable accommodation for different charismas and styles, including those who are more traditional, and I think that’s the trend now,” the Pillar reported officials as saying.

While critics would be quick to point to the ever evolving story of the Ad Petri Sedam’s experiences this year as an example to the contrary, evidence suggests that, while it was made known in December after a private audience with Bishop Athanasius Schneider that the Pope was concerned about possible “instrumentalization” of last year’s Mass in St. Peter’s, the ultimate decision was made by the Secretariat of State, with communications being sent from the Substitute of the Secretariat, Archbishop Paolo Rudelli. If the decision came from Leo himself, it likely would have been communicated through the Prefecture of the Papal Household.

The other factors in this situation have to do with the nature of the long-expected departure of Cardinal Mauro Gambetti, O.F.M. Conv. as Archpriest of St. Peter’s Basilica after a tumultuous five years. Word of Gambetti’s eventual ouster had been penned since the summer of 2025, with steam picking up this past July when word began to emerge that he would be named Archbishop of Cheitti-Vasto. Incidentally, July was also when the orginizers of the annual TLM pilgrimage were told by Cardinal Gambetti that the decision was out of his hands & that they would now have to go through the Secretariat of State. During this time, no less than six rummored names of possible successors to Gambetti began to appear. These included Saint Mary Major Archpriest Cardinal Makrickas, Pro-Prefect for the New Evangelization of the Dicastery for Evangelization Rino Fisichella, the current Papal Master of Ceremonies Archbishop Diego Ravelli, Bishop of Tortona & former Papal M.C. Guido Marini, & Bishop of Pavia Corrado Sanguineti. But, prior to all of those names being dropped, Edgar Beltran noted the first name on the list of consideration was the Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin.

That the switch in dealing directly with Cardinal Gambetti concerning the annual Pilgrimage to the Secretariat of State for the TLM organizations came right as the news of Cardinal Parolin, who reportedly lost the 2025 Conclave in large part due to the organizational efforts of the Erdo bloc, headed by American Cardinals Burke, Dolan, & DiNardo, possibly becoming Archpriest is not a point that should be discounted. Il Tempo reported in August that the Erdo bloc believed Parolin couldn’t be trusted & thus decided to move their votes to Cardinal Prevost en masse during Round 2 of voting.

The possibility of Parolin, through Archbishop Rudelli (who, while considered, “methodical, non-ideological, and profoundly intellectual”, is known to be close to Cardinal Parolin), denying the pilgrimage access for that reason should not be entirely discounted.

If anything, that scenerio takes the spotlight & pressure of the decision off of Pope Leo entirely.

Leo’s appointment of Gambetti’s sucessor, then, came as something of a shock when the news of the appointment of Divine Worship Secretary, Archbishop Vittorio Francesco Viola, O.F.M., as Archpriest of St. Peter’s was made. While it was widely known that Viola, considered the most ardent enforcer of the 2021 Motu Proprio, would not be appointed Prefect for Divine Worship, many thought he would be sent to replace the 78 year old Cardinal Marcello Semeraro as Prefect for the Causes of Saints. 

Ed Condon, in his analysis of the Viola moves, was quite pointed, saying, “the expectation around Rome regarding Viola was that he would either remain in post for the foreseeable future or, if he was someone Leo placed particular trust in, be promoted to lead a dicastery in due course. Neither has happened. Instead, by giving him the job at St. Peter’s, Leo seems to have moved Viola out of a position of genuine power and influence in the curia and into one with decidedly less reach, globally and around Rome.” 

But Ed notes that while Leo’s puzzling pick may be an odd choice to “turn the page” on Gambetti, that Viola has the reputation of being very competent in administrative matters. 

This could mean that the move to St. Peter’s might not have anything to do with Viola’s views on the Usus Antiquor, as Ed notes that the word in Rome was that Leo was prepared to move Makrickas to St. Peter’s & Viola to St. Mary Major.

However, the prevailing opinion is that the Lithuanian Archpriest of the Liberian Basilica turned down the transfer, after only being St. Mary Major Archpriest since July 2025 & serving two years prior as Codjutor cleaning up a major mess of the Basilica’s administration. To be asked to go clean up the mess of another Papal Basilica after only being in your post for one year is not something people would normally say yes to. This resulted in Viola getting St. Peter’s instead.

At the very least, the transfer formally moves Viola & his views on the TLM out of the Curia proper & out of more possible influence, even though he remains inside the Vatican Basilica itself.

The Franciscan Prelate’s opinion on the Tridentine Missal to one side, a final factor that has gone unmentioned by most, yet pointed out by both The Pillar & Andrea Gagliarduci, is that Viola himself celebrates the Mass with particular reverence, with Gagliarcuci outright describing his liturgies as “rigorous” & “impeccable” with The Catholic Traveler noting that Viola has often celebrated Mass ad orientem.




Bishop Guido Marini of Tortona (Left) embracing Archbishop Viola OFM (Right). Credit: C.P. San Marziano Tortona

Share The Walking Hymnal

What the new Synod Secretariat appointment could signify

Appointing a well-known liturgist such as Sister Elena, with a particular focus on sacred music as Undersecretary of the Synod of Bishops may still be viewed, much like his other liturgical appointments, as an odd move on the part of the Holy Father.

Unless Leo has other plans up the slevee of his cassock.

Pope Leo has not taken any hard stance (or any stance) publicily about Traditionis Custodes, nor has Sister Elena. But, from what the Chicago Pontiff’s own actions have demonstrated, in addition to what is known about his insistance on correct liturgical attention in Peru, this latest move could signify a continued move towards tightening up abuses regarding the celebration of the Missal of Pope Paul VI.

That Sister Elena was not appointed to a position on the Dicastery for Divine Worship & the Discipline of the Sacraments (a Dicastery of which she is neither a member nor consultant), but instead the Secretariat of the Synod of Bishops, could indicate how Pope Leo intends to use the Synod in regards to bringing about unity among the bishops concerning the Sacred Liturgy moving forward. As Andrea Gagliarduci pointed out concerning the surprise of Viola’s Basilica appointment, it really demonstrates “that the problem isn’t simply interpreting the Pope with old categories. Rather, it’s believing those old categories still hold.”

This, then, becomes another move in how Pope Leo is beginning to shift his Curia into place, & in this case, pointing the Synod of Bishops in a new & very clear liturgical direction.

But in any case, it does not seem that Pope Leo wishes to follow Sister Nathalie Becquart & “sing a new Church into being”, but rather, with the appointment of Sister Elena Massimi, stear the barque of Peter towards “a true path of balence.”

More: https://x.com/walkinghymnal/status/2116358347708313716?s=46&t=IydJ-X8H6c0NM044nYKQ0w

Friday, November 13, 2026

NEWS “A path of balance has not been pursued”: What the appointment of an Italian Musical Liturgist as Undersecretary of the Synod of Bishops could signify

 

“We should ask ourselves whether all this hasn’t actually led to a secularization of the liturgy, distancing itself, without careful discernment, from what came before.”

On Friday, October 30th, Pope Leo XIV appointed Father Giacomo Costa, S.J. & Sister Elena Massimi, F.M.A. as Undersecretaries of the Synod of Bishops. With these double appointments, the Holy Father replaces Sister Nathalie Becquart as the remaining Synod Undersecretary while at the same time filling the spot he left vacant by his March 2026 appointment of the Spanish Augustinian Archbishop Luis Marín de San Martín, O.S.A. as Prefect for the Dicastery for the Service of Charity & Papal Almoner.

Photo by Tomasz Zielonka on Unsplash


At the time of this writing, no new assignment has been announced for Sister Becquart. Father Costa, S.J. has been known in the world of the Synod of Bishops for years, & generally considered a solid pair of hands. The Jesuit priest, who until today was a consultor to the Synod’s General Secretariat, served as special Secretary for the Synods on Youth in 2018 & on Syndodality from 2021 to 2024 respectively. He was also the front man for the Ecclesiastical Meeting on Amoris Laetitia earlier this month.

But the name of Sister Elena Massimi, while not known to many in the world of synoding, should at the very least be passively familiar & known to those who run in liturgical music circles. And, as such, is both an intriguing surprise of Leo & could be a possible indication of his next moves.

The author of several books on the post-conciliar liturgical reform, Sister Elena is a member of the Institute of the Daughters of Mary Help of Christians, the Salesian Sisters of Don Bosco, professing final vows in 2009. According to the Bollettino, she is currently a professor of liturgy at the Pontifical Salesian University & “was awarded a doctorate in sacred theology, with a liturgical-pastoral specialization [from] the ‘Santa Giustina’ Institute of Pastoral Liturgy in Padua, part of the Faculty of Theology at the Pontifical University of Saint Anselm in Rome.” She is also President of the Italian Association of Professors and Scholars of Liturgy, a post she was elected to in 2022.

 According to the press release by her Order at the time of her election as President of the APL, the purpose of the Association “is to promote, update, and qualify the study and teaching of the Liturgy in theological Faculties, in Religious Seminaries and Studentates or in other Institutes of Religious Sciences, according to the spirit of Sacrosanctum Concilium 16 and Optatam Totius 16 and the norms of the Ratio Studiorum for Seminaries. It also intends to collaborate, in its specific field, in the promotion of liturgical life in the Italian Church and favor the formation of the clergy in the liturgical field.”

More: https://x.com/walkinghymnal/status/2116358347708313716?s=46&t=IydJ-X8H6c0NM044nYKQ0w


Thank you for visiting.

Followers

Kamsahamnida, Dziekuje, Terima kasih, Doh je, Grazie, Tesekur, Gracias, Dank u, Shukran

free counters