A Vatican decree declared Cardinal Anders Arborelius’ 2024 suspension of a traditionalist priest invalid, but the diocese reportedly withheld it from clergy and faithful for months.

VATICAN CITY (LifeSiteNews) — The Diocese of Stockholm kept silent for nearly four months about a Vatican decree declaring “invalid” Cardinal Anders Arborelius’ 2024 suspension of a traditionalist priest while failing to provide the financial support required by the decree, according to investigative reporting by Diane Montagna.
“When no response or reaction came from the Cardinal, I was compelled to bring the matter to the attention of the Holy See … with a copy to the Cardinal and the Nuncio. I later also sent the original to Rome. The (Dicastery for) Clergy has confirmed that they received it,” Father Tobias Unnerstål said in a September 3 letter addressed to his benefactors.
Unnerstål had led Christ the King Parish in Gothenburg, Sweden, since 2007. The parish flourished under his traditionalist leadership.
However, his traditional Catholic spirituality subsequently became a point of contention within the local curia. After being accused of “emotional, psychological, and spiritual abuse” and suspended, the priest appealed to Rome. Although the Dicastery for Clergy ultimately found the suspension invalid, the decree imposed separate three-year restrictions on Unnerstål’s ministry. This decree was reportedly withheld by the Stockholm chancery.
A separate appeal is currently pending before the Apostolic Signatura, seeking the removal of a series of pastoral restrictions imposed by the diocese and subsequently upheld by the Dicastery for the Clergy.
Montagna brought international attention to the case, independently reconstructing and verifying allegations detailed in a dossier produced by a group of lay Catholics from Unnerstål’s diocese to show the “serious irregularities” of the Church in Sweden. The “Thomas More Report,” compiled over the course of two years, is now available in both Swedish and English.
Problems with diocesan authorities began in October 2020 when Cardinal Arborelius and Vicar General Father Pascal-René Lung formally approved, in writing, Unnerstål’s proposal to establish an Oratory modeled on that of St. Philip Neri. The following year, on February 15, a seminarian, Joseph Rizk, filed a complaint against Unnerstål, alleging “emotional, psychological, and spiritual abuse.” On April 22, the Swedish priest was summoned and questioned by the vicar general but was not allowed to see the text of the complaint against him.
On August 7, 2021, however, Unnerstål was contacted by a parishioner who showed him a letter circulated by the then-assistant parish administrator, Birgitta Gelotte. In the letter, Gelotte explained that every effort had to be made to block the traditional Oratory project and that she found in Rizk a useful ally.
“Rumours had begun to spread that Fr. Tobias … wanted to start a (Traditional) Oratory. I knew I had to do everything I could to stop it,” Gelotte wrote.
According to the Thomas More Report, as early as 2019, Gelotte had been telling other clergy members that Unnerstål was an alcoholic and homosexual in an apparent effort to discredit him. Although the search reportedly produced no compromising material concerning Unnerstål, the former parish assistant apparently obtained permission from the diocese to search the parish’s computer servers for compromising photographs. The search yielded only a single photograph of Rizk wearing a T-shirt and swim shorts during a parish trip to Malta.
In mid-August 2021, Unnerstål reportedly showed the letter to the vicar general. Although the latter promised that he would take steps to address Gelotte’s conduct, he ultimately did no more than call her to warn that Unnerstål was in possession of the letter.


