Tuesday, June 2, 2026

Monsignor Bux: ‘The crisis of the liturgy is the crisis of the Church’

 

Niwa Limbu

May. 7, 2026


Monsignor Bux: ‘The crisis of the liturgy is the crisis of the Church’
0










Monsignor Nicola Bux speaks to AdVaticanum about the SSPX, Traditionis Custodes, the “reform of the reform”, women’s ordination, Anglicanism and what he describes as the Church’s liturgical and doctrinal crisis under the post-conciliar era

Monsignor Nicholas Bux is a priest and theologian whose work has spanned academia, pastoral ministry and service to the Roman Curia. Born in Bari, southern Italy, in 1947 into a modest family, he studied at the Pontifical Gregorian University before being ordained in 1975 by Archbishop Anastasio Ballestrero, the Discalced Carmelite archbishop later known for overseeing the first modern scientific examination of the Shroud of Turin in 1978.

A specialist in Eastern liturgy and sacramental theology, he obtained a doctorate at the Pontifical Oriental Institute and went on to teach in his native Bari, Jerusalem and Rome. His service to the Holy See began under Pope John Paul II, who appointed him a consultant to the Congregation for the Causes of Saints and the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. A collaborator of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, later Pope Benedict XVI, he contributed to synodal preparations and Eucharistic texts, and later served during Benedict XVI’s pontificate in roles connected to synodal assemblies and papal liturgies.

AV: Monsignor Bux, since leaving Rome and your responsibilities in the Roman Curia, what have you been doing? How have you been spending your time? Are there any particular projects, writings or pastoral activities you are currently working on? How did your work and apostolate develop following the resignation of Pope Benedict XVI, particularly during the pontificate of Pope Francis?

Monsignor Nicholas Bux: After concluding my collaboration with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the Office for the Liturgical Celebrations of the Supreme Pontiff upon Benedict XVI’s resignation, I continued working until 2019 with the Congregation for the Causes of Saints and until 2021 with the Congregation for Divine Worship. Having reached the age limit for teaching theology in a faculty, I have continued giving conferences in Italy and abroad, and publishing on topics related to Eastern liturgy, ecclesiology and ecumenism.

During the pontificate of Pope Francis, in which the Magisterium experienced a serious crisis, I devoted myself to explaining the reasons why one must remain in the Church, resisting despotic forms and avoiding the mistake of placing oneself outside it. By dying within the Church – like the grain of wheat that falls to the earth – one contributes to overcoming the crisis and renewing it. Together with theologian friends, we promoted the Scuola Ecclesia Mater, an Italian network of clerics and laity, with study sessions and spiritual exercises.

Along with Cardinals Caffarra, Brandmüller, Burke and Sarah, we continue to advance the idea and practice of the “reform of the reform” of the liturgy and the Church according to the thought of Pope Benedict, as well as the international Summorum Pontificum pilgrimage at the end of October in Rome.

I can say, in light of the Pope’s latest address to the French bishops, that we were right.

AV: Looking back on the years spent in the Curia, particularly your service at the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, what were the most significant challenges or moments you faced?

NB: In 2009, after a plenary meeting of the Congregation that had decided to propose to the Pope the inclusion in the Missal of certain rites from the Vetus Ordo Missae – for example, the Offertory, to be used ad libitum – the news was leaked by someone, and an alarm was sounded by those who feared an attack on the post-conciliar liturgical reform, so everything was stopped.

Another issue we began to address was that of mega-concelebrations. The rite of concelebration promulgated by Paul VI in 1965 prescribed no more than 50 concelebrants so that they could “stand around the altar”, even if not all could immediately touch the altar table and pronounce the words of consecration over the bread and wine. These are the intention and external action required for a true concelebration and simultaneous consecration. Otherwise, saying “This is my body … this is the chalice …” does not correspond – to use the liturgists’ terms – to the truth of the sign, because one should say “That is my body …”

These are the conditions for the validity of a concelebrated Mass, so that it is sacramental and not merely a ceremony, as Pius XII affirmed. The limit set by Paul VI has disappeared in the current Missal, so doubts arise about the validity of the celebration when the number of concelebrants overflows the presbyteral area or when it takes place outdoors in enormous spaces, where non-liturgical equipment of the concelebrants is added – hats, sunglasses, water bottles and cameras.

More: https://x.com/realadvaticanum/status/2052321082980680092?s=46&t=IydJ-X8H6c0NM044nYKQ0w

Monday, June 1, 2026

United States: Ordinations in Decline

 

In the United States, the Catholic Church is facing a silent decline in vocations. An underlying question is: Can the Church regain its vitality without placing the sacred and Tradition at the heart of its mission?

The Illusion of Stability

For two decades, priestly ordinations in the United States have been plagued by chronic stagnation. It is a kind of plateau that actually masks a profound decline. While there were approximately 454 ordinations in 2005, the figure for 2025 is projected to reach a paltry 428. Over the past twenty years, the number of new priests has consistently fluctuated between 450 and 550 per year.

This figure might appear stable to a casual observer. Yet, it represents a true demographic low. To compensate for the retirement and death of the massive "baby boom" generation, the American Church would need 1,000 ordinations annually.

With less than half the necessary numbers, the priesthood is shrinking: from 42,000 priests in 2005, the United States now has only 34,000. This silent hemorrhage testifies to a crisis that discourses on inclusion struggle to conceal.

A Classic Talent Pool 

The report from the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) details the origins of the priests to be ordained this year in the United States: 62% are white, 17% Hispanic or Latino, and 11% Asian. African Americans make up only 5%. 74% were born in the United States. 5% come from Vietnam, 3% from Mexico, 2% from Colombia, and 16% from other countries.

The pool of vocations remains quite classic: 79% of future priests indicated that they had been active in parish life as altar boys, youth activity leaders, or catechists. For 70% of them, the figure of the parish priest they attended played a major role in their vocation.

CARA also notes that 93% of those preparing for ordination were baptized Catholic at a very young age. In 86% of cases, both their parents were Catholic. Only 7% converted to Catholicism later in life. 28% of those preparing for ordination had a parent who was a priest or religious. 96% have one or more siblings.

The Trap of Anti-Trumpism?

How can we explain the observed decline? It is clear that a significant portion of the American episcopate seems to have succumbed to internal secularization.

By prioritizing social themes (unconditional defense of migrants, integral ecology, or the fight against climate change) at the expense of preaching about the last things and holiness, the Church has sometimes transformed itself into a kind of confessional NGO, a phenomenon that the late Pope Francis denounced — paradoxically — in his time.

When some bishops systematically relay voices opposed to the actions of the Trump administration, they often forget that the heart of the priesthood does not consist primarily in managing migration flows, but first and foremost in the salvation of souls.

In the United States, as on the other side of the Atlantic, the future of Catholicism lies not in surrendering to the spirit of the times, but in rediscovering Tradition. The few American dioceses whose seminaries are filling up are those that are following this trend.

(Source : cath.ch – FSSPX.Actualités) Illustration : Flickr / Diocese of Sacramento (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

    Sunday, May 31, 2026

    Waiting for a State of Emergency

    The Church’s 'state of emergency' is exemplified by this: that for Rome, the only unforgivable sin is noticing there is a problem.

    You may have heard the rumors recently that, should the Society of St. Pius X go through with consecrating new bishops in July, the Vatican plans to excommunicate not only the bishops involved, but every single priest of that society as well. You may also know that the leaders of the Society of St. Pius X have appealed to a state of emergency in the Church to justify the consecrations in defiance of Rome’s wishes, stating that the salvation of souls takes precedence over obedience to the Holy See. The Vatican denies this, seeing only disobedience and, apparently, the intention to start a “new” church in the proposed consecrations; it is this charge of schism, of intending to break away, which is the given reason for the excommunication.

    What I find interesting in this dispute is the whole notion of a “state of emergency.” I do not know if it has a specific meaning in canon law, about which I am wholly ignorant, but I do know that it is largely a political term of art, referring to when the normal workings of government, the constitution, are suspended or some sort of calamity has rendered their operations null and void. It has a history in civic legal systems, but alas, I am ignorant of those as well. Perhaps there is some esoteric reason for it that I am simply too ignorant to understand, but the assertion that the Church is obviously not in a state of emergency seems—well, it seems deranged to the point of madness, as of someone who is suffering a psychotic break with reality.

    More:  https://x.com/pontificatormax/status/2051661883489308761?s=46&t=IydJ-X8H6c0NM044nYKQ0w

    Dominica Sanctissimae Trinitatis: The Mercy Hidden in the Mystery No Man Can Master

    Trinity Sunday teaches the Catholic soul to adore before it explains, to suffer without panic, and to live every ordinary duty in the Name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost.

    After Pentecost, the Church Makes Us Look Up

    The Church does something very wise on the Sunday after Pentecost. Having shown us the fire of the Holy Ghost descending upon the Apostles, she immediately raises our eyes to the eternal source from which all grace comes: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, one God in three divine Persons.

    Dom Guéranger’s Liturgical Year explains the fittingness of this placement. After Pentecost, the Apostles go forth to teach all nations and baptize in the Name of the Holy Trinity; therefore the feast honoring “One God in Three Persons” rightly follows Pentecost. He adds that all liturgical homage has the Holy Trinity as its object, since the Trinity is “the foundation of all others, and the source of all grace.”

    That is why the Introit does not begin with speculation, argument, or apology. It begins with blessing.

    “Blessed be the Holy Trinity and undivided Unity: we will give glory to Him, because He has shown His mercy to us.”

    There is the whole feast in one sentence. The greatest mystery of the Christian religion is approached through gratitude. We bless the Trinity because God has shown mercy to us.

    A child learning the Sign of the Cross may understand less theology than a professor, yet he may be nearer the heart of the feast. His little hand rises to the forehead, descends to the breast, moves from shoulder to shoulder, and the whole body is marked with the Name into which he was baptized. Before he can explain the Trinity, he belongs to the Trinity.

    That is the Catholic order. First worship, then understanding. First the knee bends, then the mind is enlightened.

    The Mystery That Humbles Without Crushing

    The Collect asks God that, “in the confession of the true faith,” we may acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity and adore Unity in the power of divine Majesty. Then it asks for protection: “that in the firmness of this faith we may ever be protected from all harm.”

    That phrase is worth lingering over. The Church does not treat the doctrine of the Trinity as an abstract puzzle for the clever. She treats it as armor.

    The Roman Catechism teaches that in one divine nature there are three Persons: the Father unbegotten, the Son begotten of the Father before all ages, and the Holy Ghost proceeding from the Father and the Son from eternity. It warns that curious inquiry into this mystery is dangerous when detached from reverence, and urges the faithful to adore “distinction in the Persons, unity in the essence, and equality in the Trinity.”

    The old Baltimore Catechism says the same thing with the clarity of a school bell: the Blessed Trinity is “one and the same God in three divine Persons,” really distinct from one another, perfectly equal, and one because they possess one and the same divine nature. It also reminds us that this is a supernatural mystery, a truth we cannot fully understand but firmly believe because God has revealed it.

    Modern man wants a God small enough to manage. The Catholic wants the living God, even if he must fall silent before Him.

    Picture a man sitting in a hospital corridor at two in the morning. His wife is behind a closed door. His phone is dead. The vending machine light flickers. He has already prayed every prayer he knows, then prayed them badly, then prayed without words. At that hour, he does not need a god who can be reduced to a slogan. He needs the God from whom, through whom, and unto whom are all things.

    He needs the Father who made him, the Son who redeemed him, and the Holy Ghost who can still breathe charity into a heart terrified by suffering.

    The Trinity is not an escape from life’s pain. It is the truth that makes pain bearable, because above every confusion stands eternal Wisdom, eternal Love, eternal Life.

    “Oh, the Depth”

    The Epistle from Romans is one of those moments when St. Paul seems to reach the edge of human speech and stop. “Oh, the depth of the riches of the wisdom and of the knowledge of God! How incomprehensible are His judgments and how unsearchable His ways!”

    Haydock’s commentary notes that after speaking of grace, predestination, mercy, and justice, St. Paul breaks into this exclamation to teach submission of judgment before the secrets of Providence. No man first gives to God so that God becomes his debtor; all things are from Him, governed by Him, and directed to His glory.

    This is where many souls lose peace. They can accept the Trinity in the catechism, yet resist the Trinity in Providence. They profess that God is infinite wisdom, then become frantic when His wisdom does not explain itself on their schedule.

    A mother once taught her little girl embroidery. From underneath the cloth she saw only knots, crossed threads, and ugly tangles. From above, the mother saw the pattern. One day, when she complained that the underside looked like a mess, the mother turned the hoop over and showed her the flower.

    That story may be simple, but St. Paul gives the adult version. We are living beneath the embroidery of Providence. We see the underside: delayed answers, humiliations, illnesses, disappointments, family griefs, betrayals, unanswered questions, and the sins we thought we had conquered rising again like weeds after rain.

    God sees the pattern.

    Faith does not require us to pretend the underside is beautiful. Faith teaches us that the underside is not the whole cloth.

    “Oh, the depth.”

    The soul that can say those words in darkness has already begun to adore.

    The Mercy of Being Small

    The modern world flatters man by telling him he is autonomous. The Trinity saves him by revealing that he is dependent.

    “For from Him and through Him and unto Him are all things.”

    From Him: every breath, every hour, every child, every loaf of bread, every absolution, every grace.

    Through Him: every good action, every act of patience, every confession made after shame, every temptation resisted, every prayer whispered with no sweetness.

    Unto Him: every duty, every suffering, every hidden sacrifice, every Mass, every deathbed, every grave, every resurrection.

    A young lawyer works late, exhausted and irritated. He has spent the day fighting petty office politics, answering emails, and wondering whether any of it matters. On the train home, he sees an old woman make the Sign of the Cross before eating a sandwich wrapped in foil. No drama, no audience, no spiritual performance. Just gratitude.

    In that small gesture is more wisdom than in a thousand self help manifestos. She knows the sandwich comes from God. She knows her life is moving toward God. She knows she eats, breathes, suffers, and hopes under the sign of the Trinity.

    That is the Catholic life. It is not lived only in choirs, monasteries, and feast day processions. It is lived in kitchens, hospital rooms, traffic, courtrooms, offices, nurseries, and lonely apartments where someone still says, “Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost.”

    The Name Into Which We Were Claimed

    The Gospel gives the great Trinitarian commission.

    “All power in heaven and on earth has been given to Me. Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.”

    The Catena Aurea, gathering the Fathers on this passage, records St. Jerome’s point that naming the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost is naming one God, since their Godhead is one. It also gives St. John Chrysostom’s consoling gloss on Christ’s promise to remain with His own: the Lord tells His disciples not to fear the difficulty of their mission, because He is with them and can make all things easy.

    Haydock makes the same Catholic point: in baptism we are made Christians in the Name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, professing faith, hope, service, and adoration toward the same three divine Persons; Christ’s promise to be with His Church “all days” extends to the successors of the Apostles until the consummation of the world.

    There is something almost terrifying in the tenderness of that. We were not baptized into an idea. We were not baptized into a religious mood. We were baptized into the Name.

    A name means possession. A soldier wears the insignia of his country. A bride receives a name as a sign of covenant. A child bears the family name before he understands the duties and inheritance attached to it.

    The Christian bears the Name of the Trinity.

    That means your ordinary life is not ordinary in the way the world thinks. Your body was washed in that Name. Your soul was claimed in that Name. Your forehead has been signed again and again in that Name. Your sins are absolved in that Name. Your coffin will be blessed in that Name.

    The question is whether your life gives glory to that Name.

    Teaching Them to Observe

    Christ does not say merely, “Teach them interesting doctrines.” He says, “Teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you.”

    There is the forgotten half of Catholic formation. Doctrine must become obedience. Adoration must become life. The Trinity must move from the catechism page into the conscience.

    A man can defend the filioque online and still be cruel to his wife. A woman can know the Athanasian Creed and still nurse envy. A teenager can serve the old Mass beautifully and still live a double life on his phone. A father can demand reverence in church while bringing none of it home.

    The Gospel will not allow that division. Baptize them. Teach them. Then teach them to observe.

    The Trinity leaves fingerprints on the moral life. The Father teaches us gratitude and obedience. The Son teaches us sacrifice and truth. The Holy Ghost teaches us charity and purity of heart.

    So the feast asks practical questions.

    Does my home reflect order, or only appetite?

    Does my speech give glory to God, or does it spread irritation, gossip, and contempt?

    Do I make the Sign of the Cross like a Catholic, or like a man swatting a fly?

    Do I invoke the Trinity in prayer, then live as if my time, money, body, and opinions belong only to myself?

    The faith protects us from harm when we live inside it. A castle protects the man who enters it, not the man who admires it from the road.

    The Trinity and the Family

    Every human analogy limps before the Trinity, and the Church rightly warns us not to reduce divine mystery to creaturely images. Still, the Christian home can reflect something of God’s order by grace.

    The Father is not solitary power. The Son is not rebellion. The Holy Ghost is not sentiment. In God there is eternal relation, eternal knowledge, eternal love, without confusion and without division.

    A Catholic family learns from this. Authority should be fruitful, not selfish. Obedience should be noble, not servile. Love should be sacrificial, not indulgent.

    Imagine a father coming home after a brutal day. He wants silence. He wants a drink. He wants everyone to leave him alone. His youngest child runs to him with a broken toy and an urgent request that, in adult terms, means nothing. The father almost snaps. Then, by grace, he remembers: from Him, through Him, unto Him.

    So he kneels down.

    The toy is repaired badly. The child is delighted. The father’s evening is interrupted, yet his soul is more ordered than it was ten minutes earlier.

    That little conquest matters. The Trinity is glorified when a father acts like a father under God, when a mother loves with patient strength, when children obey with trust, when forgiveness is asked before bedtime, when the home becomes a small school of charity rather than a hotel for competing egos.

    The greatest dogma in the Faith reaches all the way down to the tone of voice used at the dinner table.

    The Trinity and Suffering

    The Gradual blesses God “Who look into the depths from Your throne upon the Cherubim.”

    That line should comfort anyone who feels unseen. God looks into the depths.

    He looks into the depth of the grieving heart.

    He looks into the depth of the conscience ashamed of repeated sin.

    He looks into the depth of a marriage under strain.

    He looks into the depth of an old man’s loneliness.

    He looks into the depth of the convert who wonders why grace has made life harder rather than easier.

    The Trinity is not far away because He is high. His height makes His nearness possible. A god who is merely part of the world can only stand beside one suffering creature at a time. The living God, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, is nearer to the soul than the soul is to itself.

    A woman kneels in the back pew after Mass. She has not received because she needs confession. She feels unworthy even to remain in the church. The sanctuary lamp burns quietly. Nothing dramatic happens. No vision. No voice. Yet she says, “Blessed be the Holy Trinity and undivided Unity, because He has shown His mercy to us.”

    That prayer is already a door opening.

    The Father is calling her home. The Son has already shed the Blood that can cleanse her. The Holy Ghost is moving her to repentance.

    The Trinity is not a doctrine for the sinless. The Introit says mercy.

    The Mass as Trinitarian Worship

    The Secret asks God to hallow the sacrificial offering and “through it to make us an eternal offering” to Him.

    This is one of the most beautiful petitions in the Mass. The offering on the altar is Christ. Yet the Church asks that we, too, be made an offering. The baptized soul must become what the Mass teaches it to be: something handed over to God.

    Guéranger later observes that the Holy Eucharist is the best means by which we give worship to the three divine Persons, and that it is also the bond uniting earth with heaven.

    That is the secret of Catholic worship. We do not climb to the Trinity by our own eloquence. We are carried by the Sacrifice of the Son to the Father in the unity of the Holy Ghost.

    This is why careless worship wounds the Catholic instinct so deeply. At Mass, we are not holding a meeting, staging a lesson, or expressing a community mood. We are being drawn into the supreme act of adoration. The Son offers Himself to the Father. The Holy Ghost sanctifies. The Church, gathered into Christ’s sacrifice, gives glory to the undivided Trinity.

    The most important thing happening in the world on Trinity Sunday may be hidden under the appearance of bread and wine.

    Before All Living, We Will Praise Him

    The Communion antiphon says: “We bless the God of heaven, and before all living we will praise Him; because He has shown His mercy to us.”

    Before all living.

    That means the faith is public. A Catholic should not flaunt piety like a costume, but neither should he hide gratitude like contraband.

    Make the Sign of the Cross before meals in public.

    Say grace when company is present.

    Bless your children without embarrassment.

    Keep holy water by the door.

    Let your home contain visible signs that God is worshipped there.

    Speak the Name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost with reverence.

    A man who cannot bless himself in a restaurant will struggle to confess Christ before persecutors. Courage usually begins in small acts. Cowardice does too.

    The old Catholic world understood this better than we do. Bells rang. Processions moved through streets. Farmers blessed fields. Mothers taught children to cross themselves before sleep. Men removed hats before churches. Time itself was punctuated by the Angelus, the liturgical year, the saints, the fasts, the feasts, the Mass.

    Trinity Sunday gathers all of that into one act of praise.

    Blessed be the Holy Trinity and undivided Unity.

    Firmness of Faith

    The Postcommunion asks that the reception of the sacrament and the profession of faith in the eternal Holy Trinity and undivided Unity may benefit us “for the salvation of body and soul.”

    Body and soul. The whole man must be saved.

    The doctrine of the Trinity guards the mind from error, but it also heals the person. It teaches the proud intellect to kneel. It teaches the anxious heart to trust. It teaches the lonely soul that ultimate reality is not isolation but eternal life, knowledge, and love. It teaches the sinner that mercy is not an afterthought in God.

    The Father did not begin loving when we began existing. The Son did not become lovable when He became man. The Holy Ghost did not begin proceeding when He descended at Pentecost.

    Before creation, before Bethlehem, before Calvary, before the tomb, before the font where you were baptized, God was eternally blessed in Himself.

    And yet this same God has shown mercy to us.

    That is the wonder.

    The infinite Trinity has bent down to claim dust.

    The God whose judgments are incomprehensible and whose ways are unsearchable has given us His Name.

    The God whom no mind can master has made Himself the refuge of children.

    So on Trinity Sunday, the Catholic soul does not try to solve God. It adores Him. It believes Him. It blesses Him. It receives from Him, lives through Him, and returns unto Him.

    Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost.

    As it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end.

    Amen.

    Subscribe: https://bigmodernism.substack.com/subscribe?utm_source=email&utm_campaign=email-subscribe&r=2x82t4&next=https%3A%2F%2Fbigmodernism.substack.com%2Fp%2Fthe-mercy-hidden-in-the-mystery-no&utm_medium=email


    Saturday, May 30, 2026

    Cardinal Eijk on Courting and Signs of Affection




    “For boys and girls who are courting or engaged to be married, it is of course permissible to show affection for each other through hugging and kissing. The form it takes and the extent to which it is permissible depends on the circumstances and culture in which they live. These displays of affection are also necessary because it is difficult to marry someone with whom one has not established an emotional bond. Of course, it is possible for this to involve sexual arousal. In this case, there is a ‘necessary occasion for sin,’ because—as already mentioned—preparation for marriage requires both prospective marriage partners to form an affective bond with each other. They should try to avoid losing self-control in doing so by not meeting too often and for too long alone. In addition, they should frequently resort to prayer, receive the Eucharist, and, if necessary, the sacrament of penance and reconciliation. In the latter sacrament, before receiving absolution, they must make sincere efforts to the best of their ability to avoid losing self-control. However, they cannot be asked to avoid this risk altogether. It is obviously different for people who do not have the will to avoid this risk. They cannot be absolved. By the way, the confessor should realize that the guidelines given by classical moral theologians for this purpose must be applied with the necessary nuances in our time, because avoiding the opportunity to be sexually aroused has become very difficult. Think of the arousing images in advertising, on television and the internet, in reading material, and even in teaching aids.”

    (The Bond Of Love, Ch. 11, n. 11)


    Thank you for visiting.

    Followers

    Kamsahamnida, Dziekuje, Terima kasih, Doh je, Grazie, Tesekur, Gracias, Dank u, Shukran

    free counters